Whatever Happened to Amy Pond?

At the end of Cold Blood, Rory died. It was shocking enough to see this good man (a hero to some) fall victim to Silurian fire, but to also see him erased from the memory of the woman he loved was to witness his double death. And sad though it is to bid farewell to Arthur Darvill, I can’t help but wonder if his passing might at last see the return of that other wonderful companion from earlier this season… what was her name, now?

Oh yes, that was it. Amy Pond.

You remember Amy, don’t you? That feisty young woman the Doctor first met as a mysterious, almost unearthly child. She handcuffed him to a radiator, remember? Handcuffs, remember? Course you do. She helped him discover his eleventh persona and you thought she was easy on the eye. You loved that screwball comedy thing she had going on. She saw the solutions the Doctor couldn’t see and saved the day both on Starship UK and in Churchill’s Cabinet War Rooms. Not only did you like the length of her legs and the blue of her eyes, you also managed to look past them to realise she was, quite instantly, one of the most quick-witted and uncannily intuitive of all the Doctor’s companions: remember the thing with the Angel on pause? Brilliant. Amy Pond was someone we wanted to unwrap, to discover and learn about.

So where’s she been for the last few weeks?

Okay, okay, before I scare you all away, I’m not taking a pop at Karen Gillan (who, if Confidential is anything to go by, appears to be one of the most delightful people to have ever set foot on this earth), but something ‘uneven’ has happened to the character she is playing. Obviously, once the dynamic of the TARDIS crew shifted to accommodate Rory, things had to become less romantic and more awkward. The new dynamic duo was replaced by a sketchily drawn love triangle – presumably so we could see Amy wrestle with a love that would be taken from her, thus leading us towards the season’s endgame. Sadly, though, Amy took a stretch limo back seat to her fellow travellers. Those of you who simply like a Doctor Who girl to fill a pair of incredibly short shorts will wonder what I’m talking about, but aside from two genuinely moving moments (one at the end of Amy’s Choice, where Amy held Rory and Gillan’s eyes communicated so much that her frozen face could not, and the frantic Cold Blood sequence where Rory slipped from her memory) she’s had nothing truly substantial or dramatically truthful to do for four weeks.

Karen Gillan plays Doctor Who companion Amy PondThere’s been a definite ‘cruise control’ feel to the middle of this (undoubtedly wonderful) season and Gillan has come out of it the worst. Factions of the viewing public that heartily embraced the new Doctor have begun to spurn Amy. Some have expressed dissatisfaction with the character’s moral position (her intended ravishment of the Doctor on the eve of her wedding), but others have criticised Gillan’s performance. While the former position is up for some debate, the latter is, I think, unfair. Recent scripts have rarely favoured Amy and when they have they’ve made her very knowing or ironic (see her response to the 6-foot lizard man who’s just delayed her dissection). You could place such dialogue into the mouth of Runaway Bride-era Donna and it wouldn’t be out of place; it’s that grating. Some of the problems do lie in Gillan’s delivery, which now seems quite settled (while Matt Smith’s grows ever inventive), but the character is in danger of being written out of ‘feisty’ and ‘quirky’ into ‘shallow’ and ‘dangerously smug’. Perhaps the real tragedy of recent weeks was watching Amy respond to the Human/Silurian peace talks by acting bored out of her skull. It’s hard to imagine Rose, Martha or Donna doing the same; they would have been much more proactive. I’m sure Amy is too, but someone seems to have forgotten.

Or have they?

To some extent, it’s easy to feel that we might have been cheated. The Eleventh Hour promised us an enigma to be unravelled across the season – but we’re still no closer to knowing much about Amy Pond. It’s like she’s as much a void in the centre of the season as the Cheshire cat grin in time. We know nothing about her family or her lost memories. One can only assume that her parents either died after promising to ‘be back in five minutes’ or they, too, are/were/will be caught up in the collapse of the universe – but what of her aunt? And where did all her memories go? Was it the crack that took them or something more traumatic? Was she even around for the Dalek invasion? And, hey, we’re asking the questions, but does she even know who she is? She could be anyone. And I mean ANYONE (handcuffs, remember? But maybe it won’t always end like that?). All we have learnt is that she did love Rory after all. Probably.

But with her reset button pressed (one assumes only temporarily), I’m hoping the Amy we get for the next few weeks is the Amy I remember from the first five. With bits added. One hopes that Rory’s narrative presence will ultimately serve some larger dramatic purpose and that their relationship will prove to be the key to the entire season (will she remember him and be given the opportunity to reverse his death – like Anji did with Dave in the Eighth Doctor novels – thus causing universal chaos, etc?). Perhaps Rory was there to distract us from the central mystery of Amy. Which means we haven’t been cheated, then, but cleverly manipulated.

Almost ten weeks in and we’re still no closer to knowing anything about Amy Pond. And that’s probably the point.

You may also like...

No Responses

  1. Rick714 says:

    I think it depends on the script in any given week. I know she’s supposed to be a bit nuts but it’s a delicate balance between lovably nuts and down right unlikable/annoying. She was really unlikable/annoying in Victory and I found her the same in cold Blood. She was acting like the typical bored teenager during the crucial negotiations with the lead Silurian—unbelievably annoying–and acting way too casual during her escape and I found that to be annoying as well.

    Conversely, in every other episode, she struck just the right balance with a gravitas that was seemingly beyond her years. Hopefully she nails the part internally before too much longer. Otherwise, I’ll be glad to see her go.

  2. TheDarkling says:

    I like the idea that Amy is being influenced by some unknown source, with a grand, overall plot developing bit by bit. But, the casual audience won’t get that. To anyone tuning in unaware, or watching episodes out of sync, they may just think ‘who is this spoilt, moaning girl?’. That’s a real shame, as both Amy, and Karen Gillan, show plenty of potential. Chatting to fans, and casual viewers, has revealed a worrying trend in ‘I prefered Billie’ reactions. In all honesty, I am finding myself thinking the same thing, so fingers crossed for a great ‘rabbit out of the hat’ moment towards the end.

  3. Patooty says:

    I agree with *nearly* everything you say here – except for the fact that, in my opinion, Amy Pond has not been remotely interesting or engaging since we last saw her at 7 years old. I’ve spent every episode struggling to like either the character or the actress, and failing dismally at both. I never knew exactly where to place the blame for this, so I divided it equally between a badly drawn character and a talentless actress (being a girl myself, her “hawtness” pretty much just leaves me cold. I need a lot more than that to engage my attention).

    So while I haven’t given up hope that I might develop a fondness for this character – especially as the actress has signed on for another season, sadly – the astonishingly, mind-bendingly, unimaginably terrific plotting, script writing and acting that will have to pulled off in the final episode(s) to accomplish that makes my hope very faint indeed. But final judgment is reserved until the end credits of episode 13, just in case!

  4. ChrisL says:

    I am so pleased to read the above comments… y’see, I thought I was the only one who found Amy Pond irritating, annoying and completely lacking any redeeming features. I’m a standard, red blooded, heterosexual male and yet even the ridiculously short skirt doesn’t take my mind off her shortcomings.

    Every week I sit down to watch this series and try to like the girl – unfortunately, every week I fail miserably for all the same reasons as those listed above.
    Add to this the fact that Miss Gillan tends to gabble her lines in an incomprehensible rush and the whole Amy Pond character just leaves me cold.
    I keep hoping that she’ll win me over, much as Donna eventually did. I didn’t care for Donna Noble initially but she went on to become probably my favourite companion but Amy just continues to grate!

    Matt Smith has won me over completely, the show’s return to a more traditional (pre 2005) feel is also good to see, but I’m sorry… I’m so, so sorry, Miss Pond is a constant source of annoyance.

    • Spannerman says:

      I think that Doctor Who should be more akin to Steven Moffat’s other show Sherlock (which in my opinion is excellent). I dont think it should be more like the pre-2005 series at all – that’s the reason it was cancelled in 1989!

  5. Spannerman says:

    In my opinion Amy Pond (and also her wet-acting boyfriend) really brought the standard of acting in Doctor Who down. I just don’t like this sort of comedy gag thing that Steven Moffat has going on in the series all the time right now. I can’t take it seriously anymore, and for an adult viewer it is very disappointing. I think Amy Pond isn’t a good companion because she cartoonishly overacts the WHOLE time! If Doctor Who doesn’t start being cool the way it was before 2010 I think I shall stop watching it altogether.

  1. June 11, 2010

    […] Whatever Happened to Amy Pond? […]

  2. July 21, 2010

    […] Whatever Happened to Amy Pond? […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *